Do You Need to Refrigerate Pumpkin Pie? Storage Times for Pumpkin, Pecan, Sweet Potato and Fruit Pies This Thanksgiving

Share

Pie is often the last thing on the Thanksgiving table and the first thing people ask about the next morning: can it stay on the counter? For pumpkin pie the answer is no, unless it is a specific kind of store-bought pie. This explainer covers when to refrigerate pumpkin pie, how long pumpkin, pecan, sweet potato, cream and fruit pies last, how to cool and store them, the rule for store-bought pies, and how to freeze pie for later.

It is part of our Thanksgiving food safety series, alongside how to thaw a turkey, how to roast a turkey safely and make-ahead sides that reheat safely.

Do you need to refrigerate pumpkin pie?

Yes. Homemade and bakery pumpkin pie should go in the refrigerator once it has cooled, and it should not sit at room temperature for more than two hours. Iowa State University Extension’s AnswerLine explains that the USDA advises refrigerating all “egg rich pies” after baking and cooling unless they will be served within two hours of baking, and that pumpkin and pecan pies fall in this category along with custard and meringue pies.

The reason is the filling. Pumpkin pie is a custard: Wikipedia describes it as a dessert pie with a spiced, pumpkin-based custard filling, typically made with eggs and evaporated or condensed milk. NC State University notes that pies with egg fillings, such as pumpkin, custard and cream pies, pose a higher risk of microbial contamination because of their higher moisture and protein content.

Bacteria grow fastest between 40 and 140 degrees Fahrenheit, which food safety agencies call the danger zone. That is why the familiar two-hour rule applies to pumpkin pie just as it applies to turkey and stuffing.

Pie storage chart: how long each type lasts

The University of Maine Cooperative Extension publishes a pie storage chart that sorts pies into groups. Here is a summary:

Pie type Counter Refrigerator Freezer (best quality)
Pumpkin, pecan, sweet potato and other pies made with eggs No more than 2 hours Up to 4 days About 2 months
Custard, cream, chiffon and fresh fruit pies Refrigerate promptly Up to 4 days Do not freeze well
Baked fruit pies made with sugar, no eggs (apple, cherry, berry) Up to 2 days, covered 2 more days after the counter, or up to 7 days if refrigerated right away About 4 months
Pies made with sugar substitutes Refrigerate Use within 2 days About 2 months

Sweet potato pie belongs with pumpkin: it is an egg-and-milk custard pie, so it follows the same refrigeration rules.

Why can apple pie sit out? Iowa State’s AnswerLine pie storage guide explains that in fruit pies made with sugar, the combination of sugar and acid in the fruit is enough to slow bacterial growth.

What about store-bought pumpkin pie?

This is where people get confused, because many grocery stores sell pumpkin pies on unrefrigerated shelves.

According to Iowa State’s AnswerLine, commercially produced pies that are displayed and sold unrefrigerated are made with shelf-stable ingredients and antimicrobial preservatives, and typically do not need to be refrigerated until cut. NC State adds that most commercial pumpkin pies are cooked at a higher temperature, contain preservatives and have carefully controlled acidity. University of Illinois Extension says commercial pumpkin pie must reach an internal temperature of 180 degrees at its coolest point, be made under good manufacturing practices, undergo microbial testing and carry a use-by date.

What to do:

  • If the pie was refrigerated at the store, keep it refrigerated at home.
  • If it was sold on a room-temperature shelf, follow the label and the sell-by date. Once cut, refrigerate leftovers.
  • If it came from a bakery or a friend’s kitchen, treat it like homemade: refrigerate after two hours.
  • When in doubt, refrigerate it. Iowa State notes it is never wrong to store a store-bought pie in the refrigerator.

How to cool and store a homemade pumpkin pie

  1. Cool it on a rack after baking. Iowa State recommends cooling completely before covering so condensation does not form under the wrap, which leads to a soggy crust and a better environment for bacteria.
  2. If it is not cool within two hours, put it in the refrigerator uncovered to finish cooling.
  3. Once chilled, cover loosely with plastic wrap, foil, a pie cover or an upside-down bowl.
  4. Eat within four days. Label the plate if your fridge is crowded with leftovers.

Serving pie on Thanksgiving Day

  • Set a two-hour clock. Put the pie out for dessert, then return it to the fridge within two hours, or one hour if the room is hot.
  • Serving a buffet that runs long? Iowa State suggests keeping the pie chilled on ice if it needs to be out longer.
  • Whipped cream counts too. Dairy toppings should also go back in the refrigerator.
  • Traveling with pie? Carry egg-based pies in a cooler with ice packs if the trip is longer than two hours.

Can you make pumpkin pie ahead and freeze it?

Yes, with some trade-offs. Iowa State says pumpkin and pecan pies can be frozen with some success for up to two months, though the filling may separate a bit and the crust may get soggy. To freeze, wrap the cooled pie tightly in plastic wrap and foil or seal it in an airtight freezer bag. Thaw it in the refrigerator, not on the counter.

Cream and custard pies do not freeze well. Baked fruit pies freeze better: freeze uncovered until solid, then wrap, and use within about four months.

Signs a pie has gone bad

Throw it out if you see mold, notice a sour or off smell, see liquid weeping from a custard filling or if it has been left out overnight. You cannot see or smell most bacteria that cause foodborne illness, so a pumpkin pie that sat on the counter all night should be discarded even if it looks fine.

A short history of a Thanksgiving staple

Pumpkin pie was not on the menu at the 1621 harvest feast in the form we know. Wikipedia notes that pumpkin “pies” made by early colonists were more likely a savory dish cooked in a pumpkin than a sweet custard in a crust. An early appearance of a more modern, custard-like pumpkin pie was in American Cookery, published by Amelia Simmons in 1796. Today many home bakers start with canned pumpkin.

Quick answers to common pie questions

Can pumpkin pie sit out overnight? No. A homemade or bakery pumpkin pie left out overnight has spent far more than two hours in the danger zone and should be thrown away.

Does pecan pie need to be refrigerated? Yes. Pecan filling is made with eggs, so it follows the same rules as pumpkin pie: refrigerate after cooling and eat within about four days.

Is it safe to eat pumpkin pie cold? Yes. Many people prefer it chilled. If you like it warm, reheat slices briefly in the oven or microwave.

How far ahead can I bake pumpkin pie? Up to about four days ahead if you refrigerate it, or longer if you freeze it, keeping in mind the texture changes that come with freezing.

The bottom line

Pumpkin pie is a custard, so it needs the refrigerator: no more than two hours on the counter, then up to four days in the fridge. Pecan and sweet potato pies follow the same rule. Sugar-based fruit pies can stay out for up to two days. Store-bought pies sold at room temperature are a special case, so follow the label. And when you are unsure, refrigerate it.

Read more

Local News