Should You Warm Up Your Car in Winter? How Long to Idle, How to Clear Ice Fast and the ‘Puffing’ Laws That Can Get You Ticketed

Share

The first frosty mornings of the season bring back an old ritual: start the car, go back inside for a few minutes and come out to a warm cabin and a clear windshield. It feels harmless. But if you warm up your car that way, you may be wasting gas, inviting a thief and, in some states and cities, breaking the law. Here is what AAA, the U.S. Department of Energy and auto theft investigators actually say about how long to idle, the fastest safe way to clear frost and ice, and the “puffing” rules that can get you a ticket.

If you have not done your seasonal checkup yet, our guide to winterizing your car for 2026-27 covers the battery, antifreeze, wipers and emergency kit. This piece is about the few minutes between turning the key and pulling out of the driveway.

Do you need to warm up your car in winter?

Short answer: briefly, yes. For a long time, no.

AAA’s guidance on how long to warm up the engine is to start the engine and let it idle “for just a moment – about the time it takes to buckle your seatbelt and adjust your mirrors.” That short pause is enough to get oil circulating to the engine’s critical parts. AAA adds that in colder weather you can let the car idle a bit longer while you scrape frost or ice off the windows and windshield.

The federal government’s fuel economy site goes further. In its list of fuel economy myths, run by the Department of Energy and the Environmental Protection Agency, it says modern vehicles “can be driven within seconds of being started,” though the engine should not be pushed hard until it reaches normal operating temperature, and “the quickest way to warm up a vehicle’s engine is to drive it.” Its cold weather page notes that most manufacturers recommend driving off gently after about 30 seconds.

The reason: modern fuel-injected engines do not need the long warm-up older carbureted cars did, and driving gently warms everything faster than sitting still.

There are exceptions. AAA says older vehicles, especially those without fuel injection, may benefit from two to three minutes of idling, and that in extreme cold a few extra minutes can help reduce stress on the engine. A heavy towing load is another case where a slightly longer warm-up makes sense. If you live somewhere with brutal winters, AAA points to engine block heaters, which it says typically cost $50 to $200 for the part, plus installation.

What idling really costs you

Idling feels free, but it is not. The fuel economy myths page says idling can use a quarter to a half gallon of fuel per hour, depending on engine size, or about 1 to 2 cents per minute. A Department of Energy Fact of the Week found that idling for as little as 10 seconds uses more fuel than stopping and restarting the engine.

Cold weather already takes a bite out of your mileage. According to fueleconomy.gov, in city driving a conventional gasoline car’s gas mileage is roughly 15% lower at 20 degrees Fahrenheit than at 77 degrees, and it can drop as much as 24% on short trips of 3 to 4 miles. Hybrids typically lose about 30% to 34% under those conditions. As the site puts it, idling to warm up “gets 0 miles per gallon.”

With gas prices still well above last year’s levels (see our latest look at gas prices heading into the holidays), a habit of 10 minutes of idling every morning adds up over a winter.

The Department of Energy’s Alternative Fuels Data Center recommends turning the engine off when you are parked or stopped for more than 10 seconds, except in traffic, and it specifically suggests avoiding remote starters, since they encourage unnecessary idling.

The fastest safe way to clear frost and ice

The one good reason to let the engine run a little longer is visibility. You should never pull out peering through a small hole in the frost. AAA’s guide on how to de-ice your windshield lays out a routine:

  • Start the engine and set the heater to defrost. Adjust the airflow to recirculate and move the temperature to full heat. If your car has automatic climate control, just set it to defrost. If it has a heated windshield, turn it on.
  • Spray a de-icer if you want to speed things up. AAA says commercial de-icers usually contain methanol and can cost up to $15 a quart, and some contain ethylene glycol, which is poisonous to pets.
  • Or mix your own. AAA describes one part isopropyl (rubbing) alcohol to two parts water, with a few drops of dish soap. Alcohol-based mixtures freeze at around 5 degrees Fahrenheit, compared with 32 degrees for water.
  • Scrape with plastic, not metal. As the ice starts to melt, use a plastic scraper, the wipers or a rubber squeegee to clear the glass.
  • Clear every window and mirror, not just a patch in front of the steering wheel.

Prevention saves time, too. AAA says a garage or even a carport helps, and without covered parking, a windshield cover, tarp or old sheet held by the wipers works nearly as well when little snow is expected.

And skip the kettle. Pouring hot water on a frozen windshield can crack the glass, as our winterizing guide notes.

What ‘puffing’ is, and why police hate it

“Puffing” is the winter habit of starting a car and leaving it running, unlocked and unattended, while you stay indoors. The name comes from the puffs of exhaust a running car gives off in the cold.

Thieves look for exactly that. The National Insurance Crime Bureau says in its warm-up theft warning that during winter “thieves are on the lookout for vehicles warming up,” watching for the steam and then hopping in and driving off with the key already in the ignition. NICB identified 84,267 vehicles stolen with the key or fob inside in 2023.

Earlier NICB research shows the seasonal pattern. In a 2019 report covering 2016 through 2018, December was the top month for thefts of vehicles with keys left inside, followed by January, November and October, and NICB said warming and cooling vehicles “seems to have played a part.”

There is a money angle as well. NICB cautions that insurance may not cover a warm-up theft, because an owner could be considered negligent for leaving the vehicle running. Check your own policy before you assume you are covered.

Is it illegal to leave your car running unattended?

In some places, yes. Rules vary widely by state and city, so check your local laws, but here are a few real examples.

  • Colorado. State law on unattended motor vehicles (42-4-1206 C.R.S.) says no person shall let a vehicle stand unattended without first stopping the engine, locking the ignition, removing the key and setting the brake. A violation is a Class B traffic infraction. The City of Aurora says its officers do write tickets for “puffers.” Colorado’s auto theft prevention program, Lock Down Your Car, says the exception is a remote starter when the keyless fob is far enough away that the car cannot be moved.
  • Michigan. MCL 257.676 requires drivers to stop the motor and take the key before leaving a vehicle unattended on a highway, but it does not apply to a vehicle standing in place with an engaged remote start feature. A violation is a civil infraction.
  • Ohio. Ohio Revised Code 4511.661 has a similar rule, but the engine and key requirements do not apply to a vehicle parked on residential property or to a vehicle that is locked, wherever it is parked. A violation is generally a minor misdemeanor.
  • New York City. Separate from theft laws, the city limits idling for pollution reasons. According to NYC311, residents can report a vehicle parked with its engine running for more than three minutes, or more than one minute next to a school.

Remote starters, EVs and the garage

Remote starters. NICB says a remote starter is the safer choice if you are committed to warming up the car, because the engine runs while the vehicle stays locked and the key or fob is not inside. Some state laws, like Michigan’s, specifically exempt them. They still burn fuel while idling, so keep the run time short.

Electric vehicles and hybrids. AAA says EVs and hybrids do not need to warm up, and idling them can waste energy. Instead, use the climate control to heat the cabin while the car is still plugged in. Fueleconomy.gov says preheating while plugged in can extend range, and using the seat warmers instead of the cabin heater saves energy too. That matters because, by the site’s estimates, an EV’s range can drop by 41% in cold weather when the heater is used.

Never in the garage. Do not warm up a car inside a garage, even with the door open. The EPA’s carbon monoxide fact sheet warns that carbon monoxide “can build up to deadly levels, even with the garage door open,” and says that if you need to warm up your vehicle, take it out of the garage immediately after starting it.

A better cold-morning routine

Put it all together and the routine is quick:

  1. Prep the night before. Park in a garage or carport if you have one, cover the windshield if frost is forecast and lift the wipers off the glass.
  2. Start the car and stay with it. Turn on the defroster at full heat and stay outside the car while you work.
  3. Clear the glass completely. Use de-icer if needed and a plastic scraper on the windshield, rear window, side windows and mirrors. Brush off the roof, hood and lights, too.
  4. Lock up if you step away. If you must go back inside, lock the car or use a remote starter, and keep the fob with you.
  5. Drive off gently. Once you can see clearly, go. Avoid hard acceleration for the first few miles while the engine comes up to temperature.

The bottom line

You do not need to let your car run for 10 minutes on a cold morning. AAA and federal fuel economy experts say a modern car is ready to drive gently after about 30 seconds, and idling only burns fuel. The real reason to keep the engine running a little longer is to clear every window, and the real rule is to stay with the car while you do it. A few minutes with a scraper is cheaper than a ticket, and much cheaper than a stolen car.

Read more

Local News